Jump to content

phaaker

Registrants
  • Posts

    85
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by phaaker

  1. I am just trying to point out that the mechanical advantage the hook lever provides compared to the force of the fish and fight is not really going to make a whole lot of difference. True some advantage will be gained by a longer hook, but not enough to worry about. It sounds like we mostly agree. When hunting Brutus every little bit helps. BTW I am not a physics expert by any means 4 of the 5 periods I teach are biology, there is over simplification in my explanation, but many of these factors will not be significant(rod length, the angle you hold it when fighting, and how deep of water you are standing in or how far above the water would all mean more). All coming from a short hook user. Torque means more for treble hooks because they cant pivot with two buried points and will pull out a a specific amount of twisting force

  2. I am not too sure that I buy the idea that short hooks are better than long hooks because of lever action. When I use a wrench I push on the handle. I don't tie a rope to the end and hang from a flag pole, yanking on the end of the rope trying to loosen or tighten a bolt. With this said, I tie most of my flies on gamakatsu B10S hooks because they work well for the proportions I use. Most of my flies are articulated so a 6xl hook is not necessary to achieve a specific length. Most of my takes are also on the front hook (head) unless it is a smaller fish. I like the gap to shank ratio on shorter-shanked hooks and typically won't use more than a 3xl.

  3. Base off of Lynch's Drunk and Disorderly, I have a fly with an interesting problem. It has too much side to side action where it can go into a roll. It is a coated deer hair wedge shaped head, but I used an old concave double edge razor to cut the top. The action is too much. I wanted to know if anyone could suggest a technique to keep the action, but stabilize the fly. I am against mucho weighting. I will post a pic of the finished fly, send the winner a fly, and step by step recipe.

×
×
  • Create New...